epc’s posterous

Just some guy 
« Back to blog

Wanted: Home Media Server solution for normal people

For the past several years I’ve strung together multiple drives off a Mac to serve as a repository of all of our digital crap (music, movies, photos, miscellaneous other stuff).  Maybe five years ago I started using a RAID setup relying on the Mac's built-in software RAID setup.  

I've alternated between three pairs of RAID arrays (one for music, one for "other" and one for movies) and my current two pair set up (music + video on one, "projects" on the other).  

As I was walking out the door (figuratively) to go on vacation this morning, one of the slices failed on the music + movies array. There's 600Gb of mostly music (and yes, RIAA, mostly legal) and some movies.  While the other slice was functioning, I didn't want to leave and come back to having lost the whole smash.

So, I'm first copying off all of the data to a spare 1Tb drive, and then rebuilding the array.

And here's the thing, I have no idea what will happen.

This one time? At band camp? Sorry… but this one time I rebuilt a slice and the system chugged along and I discovered much to my chagrin that I had an empty 200Mb RAID setup, the software having delicately erased everything before rebuilding the array.  I'd prefer that not to happen, but there's so little transparency as to what will happen that I'm resorting to copying everything multiple times before trying the rebuild.

There's got to be an easier way.

I know of the Drobo but haven't had time to look into it.  My preference is for something that just handles this shit.  Tell me when I need to slap another drive in, that's fine, but I don't want to lose anything, and I don't want to have to think about it anymore.

Loading mentions Retweet
Posted by ed costello 

Comments (8)

May 21, 2009
ed costello said...
And as I finished this post, the entire RAID failed. 600Gb of music & movies out the door, down the street, in the river.
May 21, 2009
Frank Jania said...
Good question. I've currently got my media on a Linux server but I don't have a good backup solution for it, so when you find out, let me know.

The title of the post caught my eye b/c I though you were going to talk about the front end. What front end are you using?

I've tried running Windows Media Center and Boxee on Linux. There are some things about Boxee I don't like, but it's pretty nice otherwise.

May 21, 2009
ed costello said...
Mostly apple crap for front-end (apple tv, itunes). Biggest problem is that the apple crap assumes a 1:1 mapping of user:media. In a two-geek household this requires some deft mapping of drives over the network and I'm just getting tired of it.

I have boxee but intended to put it on one of the apple TVs and laziness got the better of me.

It's mostly a time thing for me: Sure, I know how to do this, but I'm getting tired of maintaining it myself. I read a nice article about using ZFS to set up a (practically) infinitely expandable media server box but …that puts the onus back on me to manage it.

May 21, 2009
Frank Jania said...
The Linux server is in my bedroom and I have an AppleTV in the living room. Setting up Boxee on it was surprisingly easy with the patchstick hack.

The one drawback I've experienced is that the ATV isn't quite powerful enough to run Boxee without some annoying hiccups.

If I can fix a resolution issue between my CRT based HDTV and Linux server I'd replace my ATV with that.

May 21, 2009
ed costello said...
Yeah, the Apple TV has been an incredible disappointment.
May 21, 2009
Frank Jania said...
Don't even get me started on the fact that the ATV required that I convert all media to an Apple approved format. Boxee seems to play anything.
May 21, 2009
coreyh said...
You answered your own question. Drobo does what you want. DroboPro too if you feel like futureproofing.
May 29, 2009
deancollins said...
Thecus N7700 is what you are looking for http://deancollinsblog.blogspot.com/2008/10/thecus-n7700.html
see you at BarCampNYC4 tomorrow

Leave a comment...

 
To leave a comment on this posterous, please login by clicking one of the following.
Posterous-login     Connect     twitter